I think you should try it again. Attacking and capturing objectives is difficult, but it’s about weight of numbers. Make sure that the attacking square is packed to maximum occupancy and don’t forget the support squares! Attackers can claim up to three and all you need is one unit in each of them. We find it does take a couple of goes to break the defence and you will take casualties, but it can be done. If units are damaged, swap them out to support squares for battalions still at strength. Unsupported attacks will end in failure every time.
Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCNUYwNznn-ZuNMoHoF3urwQ