Home Forums WWII Modelling Tank vs. Tank Skirmish Combat Reply To: Modelling Tank vs. Tank Skirmish Combat

#18834
War Panda
Participant

Sorry for breaking from the flow a little…From the discussion on the trail run of modifications BA’s armour

“Perhaps the StuG should have suffered an additional +1 to hit on its first shot only due to not having seen the Sherman at the start of the turn?”

 

Yeah I forgot about that and I think it makes sense for both tanks to be penalized in the first turn (in some way. And incorporating it into the “to-hit” makes most sense. My worry Rod is there’s already going to be a +1 for moving into position…will a tank want to risk it at all. And perhaps thats the point….wasn’t that the case in reality anyway.

What about the point Jack makes about penalizing a stationary tank rather than the moving one?

“The great Gaels of Ireland are the men that God made mad,
For all their wars are merry, and all their songs are sad.”