In each of them I (the player) control a host of individuals of varying number. So my question is – in these games, or other similar games – who is the player?
(pardon me if my formatting is off…still learning)
To answer your question I don’t know. Perhaps I was unclear and assumed too much, as in all my skirmish gaming is 1:1, therefore your perspective, what you can do, when, and how well is a function of “who you are.”
Mountain Man and Tribal Brave might be on close footing for woodcraft, tracking, moving silently, etc, while a homesteader or cowboy would not. A homesteader might be a reasonable shot with a long gun (hunting for food) but less capable under fire and useless with a hand gun, A cowboy might have a working skill at shooting a handgun, but would lack the skills for a hollywood style gunfight, while a lawman, bounty hunter, gunslinger, and similar might all have similar high skills. What they do in a turn is also driven by who they are, whether the decision they must make would be.
I can see that in TSATF, you would lack that same perspective.