Home Forums Horse and Musket American Civil War A hot day’s fighting at Fredericksburg (ACW)

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #175925
    Avatar photoChris Pringle
    Participant

    Well, that was more fun than I thought a doomed bloody assault against entrenched defenders was likely to be!

    Here’s an AAR with a few photos. If you’ve gamed Fredericksburg (as I’m sure many here have), I’d be interested to know how your games compared with this one.

    #175953
    Avatar photoJim Webster
    Participant

    Intriguing scenario

    https://jimssfnovelsandwargamerules.wordpress.com/

    #175954
    Avatar photoGuy Farrish
    Participant

    I remember reading about Fredericksburg many years ago in a library book – either Bruce Catton or Shelby Foote (I suspect having been inspired to read ACW history by the Action in the Platteville Valley  in Featherstone’s War Games) and thinking ‘ there’s no game to be had in this’. Now whether that was the way the book was written, or because I didn’t have the imagination, or I was coloured by the similarity to the prevailing Mud Blood and Endless Poetry view of the 1st WW which this seemed to resemble, I’m not sure. It appears I was wrong!

    I’ve played several other ACW battles – historical and fabricated scenarios but any time anyone mentioned Fredericksburg I ran a mile. Thanks for the correction!

    #175960
    Avatar photoTony S
    Participant

    I must admit at times my opponents have mentioned my tendency to aim for the thickest part of the fence.   And I think my first reading of Fredericksburg was also either Catton or Foote as well Guy.

    #175968
    Avatar photoChris Pringle
    Participant

    Matt’s draft does include a couple of options that assume different strategic choices by Burnside and allow the battle to have a very different shape. These will be interesting to try some other time.

    But even playing it ‘straight’, I think the scale of the game helps it to still be interesting and more than just a dull frontal assault. This is often the case with BBB, as the aim is for scenarios to encompass an entire battle and thus capture enough time and space to give room for changing situations and interesting decisions.

    I was a bit surprised at John being so reticent. He’s usually not shy to charge recklessly into the teeth of enemy guns – doesn’t mind the casualties so long as there’s some drama – maybe a man after your own heart, Tony!

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.