Forum Replies Created

Viewing 40 posts - 601 through 640 (of 982 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Battle of Zorndorf – Devon Wargames Group #110408
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Enjoyed that thank you.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Dark Ages Saxon cavalry #110406
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Look at their wergild it’s far too high to be that of horse slaves. From memory it’s below that of the Saxon nobles and higher than that of most other Saxons.   I’ve found no reference to Saxon horsemen in the Laws of Ine if you have one I’d be very interested.

    I wouldn’t read too much into the panels if I were looking for evidence of Anglian/Saxon cavalry.  Who are the figures depicted?  Where were the panels made?   Are they mythological figures or warriors on horseback?  If the former it doesn’t help if the latter we already knew rich Germans knew how to ride.

    As I recall Halsall’s later evidence wasn’t very good either.

    The native British military tradition from Caesar to the Picts was quite horsey.  If you are interested have a look at the surviving early Welsh poems not least the Gododdin.  I don’t doubt for a moment that aristocratic households drilled together, took part in raids together and generally honed their military skills together as much as possible.  It was what justified their status and they had to be as good as they could be.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Dark Ages Saxon cavalry #110389
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    The Laws of Ine specify ‘the King’s Welsh horsemen’ if you want to use that as a justification.  There’s no mention of the King’s Saxon Horsemen although I’m quite sure most of Ine’s nobles owned horses.

    Elite Anglian or Saxon warriors might have been able to fight when mounted but that is a different thing to operating on mass as cavalry.

    Halsall’s use of the Gododdin to support his theory of Saxon cavalry does not stand a close reading of that poem and from memory that is the only early evidence he used.

    I’d go for mounted infantry or the Welsh horsemen.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Iron Age Village #109962
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Llanmellin  sounds like an interesting story of increasing power.

    The Bellona Hill Fort was picked up for next to nothing in a Department Store clear out.  God knows how long it had been there.  I should do something with it.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Vikings! #109946
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Those Vikings look very fine Truls.  I have a load of them most unpainted because I couldn’t get them right.  I think I’ll copy your colour scheme.

    In societies where fines for transgressions ascended up the social scale a bit of colour coding would be a useful thing.  Insult a fellow farmer and you can probably weather the damage of the fine.  Do it to someone with a higher status and you pay more, perhaps more than you can comfortably afford.  Early Irish society was coded by the number of colours a person could wear more colours meant more wealth and status and a higher insult price. It was also highly litigious and kept a whole class of lawyers in comfort.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Iron Age Village #109944
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    I like that.  Should you your Silures meet with success you can add another ditch and bank and then another until you have an Oppida.  I have the old Bellona British Hill Fort but have done nothing with it yet.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Greek War of Independance in 15mm #109542
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    As I dig into this I realise I can get nearly everything I need from Minifigs Napoleonic Ottoman range.  For Greek regular infantry Minifigs 1798 Austrian Fusiliers and command do the trick if you want them in helmets. If you want them in stocking cap QRF ACW have Michigan infantry in stocking cap but sadly no command to match.  So it’s helmets for me.

    I need some Philhellenes, tricky, and to refresh me Byron.

    Estimated cost of the whole project under £70.00 but it ain’t going to get any cheaper.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone played Ager Sanguinis rules? #109508
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    That’s the lad Mike.  I read that there’s a second edition due to appear in the future.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Greek War of Independance in 15mm #109444
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    They do look good.  If I get the chance I’ll buy some.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Greek War of Independance in 15mm #109432
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Thanks I’ll keep a watchful eye.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: French and Indian Wars with R&P #109379
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    You’re on a roll keep going.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Ancients rules observations… #108812
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Not on your list but Ager Proelii by James Roach gives an interesting and fun punic wars game.  It’s a Piquet Field of Battle derived game so cards are involved.  If you can get a copy it’s certainly worth giving it a try.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: True 15mm still appeals #108557
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Much appreciated lads.

    Yeah, the old figures have a charm of their own and if you’re in the right mood it’s a treat to paint them.  Also there’s a bit of the old ‘want not waste not’ in play for me.  I could never bring myself to throw away wargame figures so if they are staying they might as well be put to use.  Here are the Patricios.

    patricios

    And the Jalisco Lancers.

    Six more figures to paint and I have enough for two sides for Rebels and Patriots.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Totentanz Miniatures Ordering Experience? #108380
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Yes, a while ago Carlists and as Nick says above no problem and great toys.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #108363
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    I was thinking that as well as being a fun set of rules for those of us who have being pushing lead for decades Rebels and Patriots is a very cost effective way of getting into the hobby.  Two sides and the rule book is likely well within the financial reach of most folk and mostly game can be as ‘historically accurate’ as you care to make it.

    In the lead up to the publication of R&P I bought Papal and Garabaldini 15mm figures in the QRF sale 20% off so it didn’t cost much to have enough for two forces of 24 points each.  The whole ‘Rampant’ thing reminds me of DBA in that respect.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #108267
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Got my copy of Rebels and Patriots yesterday and have now had a read through.  There’s a lot there and all of it looks as though it will work on the table.  So far there’s only one tweak I want to make which is to allow two units of skirmishing Mamluk cavalry to combine to produce one unit of Mamluk shock cavalry by the simple expedient of lining up next to each other.  Not bad for a rule set that majors in the North American theatre.  I’d be inclined to do the same thing for American Indians to mimic the  Comanche circle or, on foot, Woodland Indians successful sniping leading to a rush.

    Although this is billed as a skirmish set it isn’t what many of us would consider by that term.  For a start the figures fight by unit not as individuals and secondly there can be a fair number of figures on the table even at the basic 24 points a side level.

    As an example here are units for the Crimean War with their R&P unit cost and traits as you can see you can get the equivalent of brigade size games for your 24 points.

    Rebels and Patriots

    Russian line infantry, poor shots, aggressive, large unit @ 5 points.

    Cossacks, light cavalry, ‘Green’ @ 3 points.

    Skirmishers @ 2 points.

    It’s common enough to use 30 or 48 points a side so it’s not really a traditional skirmish as we once knew it.

    Overall I’m impressed with what I got for my money and think Rebels and Patriots will do just what I hoped.  I’ll likely have more to say after a first game but so far I’m happy.

    For Jay above I don’t think these rules would disappoint you.

    The figures above are all from Lancashire Games.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Command and Colors Napoleonics, a Review #108028
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Enjoyed that thanks.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #108027
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Much appreciated.  I’m painting the French camel mounted infantry at the moment I’ll post a pic here when they’re done.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #108009
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Yeah, I think it’s best to field Woodland Indians as good quality skirmishers in Rampant style games.  Non of the tribes could afford significant losses of manpower.

    I gamed Monongahela with Pike Man’s Lament and got an enjoyable afternoon and an historical result.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #107974
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    I’ve got a bag of Battle Honours ACW which are too big to fit with my QRF ACW armies.  Very nice figures though.  I’ve also got some Papal Zouaves that don’t look like the originals but with a little work could do for Canadians at Ridgeway.  Size wise they match with the Battle Honours ACW.  So that’s a thought.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Anyone for Rebels and Patriots? #107959
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Cheers KB.  I’ve high hopes of Rebels and Patriots I’ll use them for the US Mexican War and the Crimean War too.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: The Picts were they Celts ? #104344
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Test.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    It has always interested me that no one says we should dismiss Penda from the historical record before discussing Mercia. Penda, as Koch tells us, in Celtic means ‘good in chiefs’-a leading warlord or over lord.  He is today a mysterious figure yet he was undoubtedly important in his time.

    Many in Lowland Britain spoke Celtic and Latin, in the rural districts Celtic predominated.  British Latin was not debased but it tended to be old fashioned.

    The Romans didn’t withdraw or disappear from Britannia the local Imperial elite were expelled during a time of civil war in the Western Empire.  Roman Law ceased to operate, it had to as the Emperor’s writ no longer ran, and was replaced, as Ken Dark tells us, by a resurgence of native Celtic Law.

    Contacts with the Eastern Roman Empire continued and there does seem to have been a major, and successful, evangelical effort by the Christians in Britannia.

    We know quite a bit more about the ‘Age of Arthur’ than a lot of folk think-it’s just not on TV.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Entirely agree Guy, I turned it off half way through.

    It would be possible to put together an interesting programme called Arthur?  Koch on the textual evidence, Charles-Edwards on the big picture, Jim Storr on evidence of military engineering in the period and Dark on the social structure of post Roman Britain.  Alice could even front it with or without another make over. Doubt that would be commissioned though.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    I thought I’d take a look at The Braes of Killiecrankie and see what it told us.  You can read it here if you’ve a mind to and also listen to the song.

    https://youdonotknowthenorth.blogspot.com/

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Italian Wars Gendarmes #99443
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Very nice work on the Base Coat there.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Next weekend is the plan everything is painted so we are good to go.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    blb

    Here’s General Hugh Mackay the Williamite Commander at Killiecrankie.  Below we can see his regiment which is part of the Dutch Scot’s Brigade.

    There were 3 regiments in the Brigade all were at Killiecrankie.  There were also two newly raised regiments this one is Lord Kenmore’s as you can see they have not all got their uniforms yet.

    You can see the rest of the Army at:

    https://youdonotknowthenorth.blogspot.com/

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: What I Have Painted Recently #99258
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Very nice indeed Martin,

    Just on ordering Roundway from the new outfit, I ordered three lots of figures from them earlier in the year.  All of my orders arrived just fine.   Took about 3 weeks each time.

    The lack of pics on the website needs to be rectified but they are very nice figures.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Yeah, it’s grand.  So far I’ve read Balfour’s Regiment didn’t fire a shot, killed 600 with three volleys, deserted their commander who was then killed.  It’s like the X Files the truth is out there.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    This project is turning into quite a saga.  It’s not the painting, that’s proceeding nicely and my Williamite Army for Killiecrankie will be up in the next couple of days.

    No, it’s the battle itself.  Everyone more or less agrees on the outcome-it’s pretty indisputable.  Beyond that pretty much everything is disputed by someone, numbers, casualties and who fought and who fled.

    Next month Helion is publishing a book by Jonathan Oates on Killiecrankie and I’m hoping to get some clarity from it,  Meantime I’ve been digging away and I have come to a view of what happened during the battle.  It may not be the correct view but it’s sufficient to play the game.

    A learning experience I suppose and a part of the hobby I enjoy.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: (WANTED) Roundway 15 mm Medieval & Renaissance #99063
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Martin, The Keep Wargaming Crew are currently selling off some packs at a great price on ebay with pics have a gander there.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Very interesting stuff.  I guess making or commissioning a range of figures has appealed to many of us at one time or another.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    blb

    That’s the Killiecrankie Jacobites done and posted on my blog.  I realise this is the first time I’ve ever painted an army for a specific battle.  Lots of folk do and I now see the attraction.  Anyhow that’s Bonny Dundee above with the royal standard of Scotland next to him.  Below are the Jacobite cavalry.

    You can see the rest of them at this link.

    https://youdonotknowthenorth.blogspot.com/

     

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Composite of detachments I’ve since found out which saves me some painting.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Thanks Norm.  The rules as written look quite promising for this action.  The regulars when charged have to test for what range they opened fire short, effective or long.  In the battle they volleyed at 75 yards which was insufficient to stop the Highland charge.  We will see how it works out in the game.

    If anyone reading this happens to know if Lauder’s Fusiliers were a regiment or a composite of detachments I’d be grateful for the information.  There were 200 of them which inclines me to think the latter-but it could have been an understrength Battalion.

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Next post will be up in a day or two KB .  Dundee’s Horse are done!  Dundee’s standard bearer and himself have yet to arrive but two figures are not a big job. Two more Highlander figures need doing as well and that’s the last Clan unit.  It’s coming together.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Thanks lads.

    The plan is to put up the following posts:

    The Jacobite Army at Killiecrankie

    The Williamite Army at Killiecrankie

    The ground and deployment of both armies and the historical account of the battle

    The first phase of the game

    The charge begins and the effect of Williamite Fire-power

    Jacobite reaction and charge home

    A blog post on how the rules worked for this type of battle.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Apparently it does but I’m not speaking from experience yet.  Killiecrankie is a nice straight forward battle, line them up on both sides and one side charges.  I’m looking forward to the game.

    I used to play Gush’s rules too, quite liked them.

     

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

    in reply to: Grenaderkorpset. #98412
    Avatar photoOB
    Participant

    Yes, that’s the stuff.

     

    OB
    http://withob.blogspot.co.uk/

Viewing 40 posts - 601 through 640 (of 982 total)